You’ve reviewed the résumé. The candidate looks qualified. Now you want to get a feel for the person behind the application.
That makes sense. Hiring is a big investment, especially for a small business. You want someone who can do the work, communicate well, and contribute to your team.
But as the conversation lightens up, it’s easy to drift into questions that have nothing to do with the job:
“Do you have children?”
“What year did you graduate high school?”
“Have you had any health problems?”
You probably don’t mean any harm. But questions like these bring information into the room that shouldn’t affect your hiring decision. And if the candidate doesn’t get the job, they may wonder whether it did, and that could turn into a lawsuit.
Is every personal question illegal?
Not exactly. Some questions are specifically prohibited. Others aren’t banned outright, but they can later be used as evidence of discrimination.
For example, federal law prohibits covered employers from asking disability-related questions before making a conditional job offer. Other personal questions create risk because they suggest a protected characteristic played a role in your decision. And state and local laws can add protections on top of federal law.
The good news? You don’t need to memorize every legal distinction to conduct a better interview. Just start with one question for yourself: What do I actually need to know about this person’s ability to do this job?
Then build your questions from there.
Don’t ask: “Do you have children?” or “Are you planning to start a family?”
Usually, what you really want to know about is attendance, travel, or whether the candidate can work late. So ask about that instead.
Try: “This position requires two overnight trips each month. Can you meet that requirement?”
Describe the same requirements to every candidate for the role. Don’t assume a parent will be less available, or that someone without kids will always be free. Questions about pregnancy, family plans, or childcare can become evidence of discriminatory intent.
Don’t ask: “How old are you?” or “What year did you graduate high school?”
If you want to understand someone’s experience, ask about their experience, not their age or a question whose answer would divulge their age.
Ask instead, “Tell me about a project where you had to juggle competing deadlines.” This will tell you far more than a graduation date ever could.
And steer clear of comments like, “You’d be working with a much younger team. Would that bother you?” You may think you’re just checking whether they’d be comfortable. But what you’re really signaling is that age matters to you. Federal law protects applicants age 40 and older from age discrimination, and some states – like New Jersey and New York – protect applicants of any age.
Don’t ask: “Do you have any medical conditions?”
Before you make a conditional offer, don’t ask about diagnoses, medications, or medical history. Questions about family medical history are also off-limits for covered employers under federal genetic-information protections.
Instead, identify the essential duties of the job and ask about those. For example: “Can you walk me through how you’d handle this task?”
Accommodation questions require some care. Even if a disability is obvious, that doesn’t give you permission to ask about a diagnosis. A limited conversation about accommodations may be appropriate in certain situations, but a general interview shouldn’t turn into a discussion of the candidate’s health.
Don’t ask: “What religion are you?” or “Which holidays do you observe?”
If your real concern is scheduling, talk about the schedule. Don’t ask where someone worships, and don’t use religious practices to judge whether they’re right for the job.
You might say: “Our regular schedule includes Saturdays. Does that work for you?”
If a candidate mentions the need for a religious accommodation, loop in the person who handles those requests. Such a request shouldn’t lead to an automatic “no.”
Don’t ask: “What did you earn at your last job?”
This is one of those old interviewing habits that can get you into real trouble.
New Jersey and New York prohibit employers from asking about an applicant’s salary history. The simplest approach? Talk about what this job pays, not what someone else paid the candidate. You can then ask if that meets their expectations.
Try: “The salary range for this position is $X to $Y. Is that in line with what you’re looking for?”
While you’re at it, take a look at the job posting itself. New York and New Jersey’s pay-transparency laws require covered employers to include pay, benefits, and other compensation information in postings for jobs and transfer opportunities. A good interview starts with a properly written posting.
What about criminal history?
Don’t make criminal-history questions a standard part of every interview without first checking the rules that apply to you.
For example, New Jersey’s Opportunity to Compete Act bars employers from asking about criminal history until after the first interview, with limited exceptions.
New York City’s Fair Chance Act requires covered employers to wait until after they make a conditional job offer. And under both New York state and federal law, you must take additional steps before withdrawing an offer based on criminal history.
Your location, the size of your business, and the position itself can change the rules. So don’t assume the same process works everywhere you hire.
What if the candidate brings up something personal?
It happens. A candidate mentions their kids or a medical issue in passing. You don’t have to cut them off mid-sentence. Just acknowledge it politely and bring the conversation back to the job. What you shouldn’t do is ask follow-up questions that dig for more personal details.
An accommodation request is different. If a candidate asks for an adjustment, either to take part in the interview or to do the job, because of a disability, a pregnancy-related limitation, or a religious practice, make sure that request is transmitted to the person who handles it. And don’t assume it means the applicant cannot do the job.
The federal Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, for example, requires covered employers to provide reasonable accommodations for qualified applicants’ known pregnancy-related limitations, unless doing so would cause the employer an undue hardship. Many states, including New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania, have similar laws.
Prepare your questions before the conversation begins
Before your next interview with a job candidate, prepare a consistent set of core questions, decide which qualifications you’ll be evaluating, and make sure everyone on your interview team understands where the boundaries are.
When you take notes, stick to skills and experience. Leave out impressions like “too old” or “might have childcare issues.” And if a candidate raises an accommodation need, handle it through the proper process.
A good interview can be warm and conversational and still stay focused on the work. You’ll learn more about the candidate, and you’ll have a much clearer basis for deciding whom to hire.
For a quick reference you can keep on hand, download my free guide, What You Can Ask in a Job Interview: A Practical Guide for Business Owners and Hiring Managers, on the home page.
Not sure whether your interview questions are creating unnecessary risk? I can help you review your hiring process and train your managers to ask better questions. Contact Rubin Employment Law before your next round of interviews.
And check out our Peace of Mind page, for owners and leadership teams who handle ongoing employee issues and want a steady, reliable legal partner — not just help in a crisis. It’s a strong fit when you’re growing, managing risk, and need consistent direction across managers and HR.
This article provides general information, not legal advice. Requirements vary by jurisdiction, employer, and position.





0 Comments